Virginia Supreme Court Hearing: Cautiously Optimistic
Timeliness of the developer’s appeal and whether it was a necessary party questioned. The legality of Missing Middle Zoning at stake.

Supreme Court of Virginia, Richmond, VA
Supreme Court of Virginia, Richmond, VA
SUPREME COURT OF VIRGINIA HEARS ARLINGTON MISSING MIDDLE CASE
Today the Supreme Court of Virginia heard oral argument in the case of Nordgren v. Arlington County Board, the lawsuit that Arlington homeowners brought challenging the Missing Middle/Expanded Housing Option (EHO) zoning ordinance. That ordinance allowed housing up to 6 units to be built across Arlington, without notice to neighbors, without a review of the neighborhood impact of this additional density, and without approval of individual projects by the County Board.
Virginia’s highest court did not consider whether or not the trial judge was correct in ruling in September 2024 that EHO violated Virginia law and was, therefore, invalid. Instead, it reviewed a decision of the Virginia Court of Appeals in September 2025 that the trial judge should have allowed developer Wilsons Ventures to intervene in the case.
Attorney Jay O’Keeffe, representing the homeowners, noted that Wilsons Ventures’ request to intervene in the case came after the 5-day trial in 2024 was completed and the trial judge had ruled that EHO was invalid. In response to Justice Arthur Kelsey’s question about whether Wilsons Ventures was a necessary party to the case, Mr. O’Keeffe responded that it was not because the case was a challenge to the EHO ordinance and the developer never stated what evidence or arguments it would have added beyond what Arlington County presented at trial.
Several Justices commented on the homeowners’ argument that the developer’s appeal of the trial judge’s decision denying intervention came after the deadline to file such an appeal had passed. They noted that allowing a stay order to extend the time for filing an appeal, as Wilsons Ventures claimed in the Court of Appeals, would fundamentally change the rule that appeals must be filed within 30 days of a final judgment.
Attorneys for Wilsons Ventures and Arlington County, who in May argued before the Court that it should not consider this case, did not appear before the Court today and did not file briefs opposing the homeowners’ appeal.
If the Court rules in favor of the homeowners, the case returns to the Court of Appeals to consider the County’s appeal of the trial judge’s ruling that EHO is invalid. After full briefing, the Court of Appeals would hear oral arguments and it could be more than a year before an opinion would be issued. The losing party can appeal that decision to the Supreme Court of Virginia.
If the Court upholds the Court of Appeals decision that Wilsons Ventures should have been allowed to intervene in the case, the matter goes to the Arlington Circuit Court for Wilsons Ventures to provide evidence and arguments about why EHO does not violate Virginia law. The trial judge would rule anew on the validity of the EHO ordinance and the losing party can appeal that decision to the Court of Appeals.
On behalf of Neighbors for Neighborhoods, which has supported the homeowners throughout the litigation, Jay Hamilton commented: “Now in its fourth year, EHO zoning has produced townhouses and duplexes that have sold and are for sale between $1.2 million and $1.6 million each. These are attainable only to high-income households, not the teachers and other moderate-income households the County Board intended to benefit from the ordinance.” He added, “EHO has failed, yet the County Board continues to defend it – spending approximately $1.6 million to a private law firm. Instead, it should focus on expanding housing that is affordable to low and moderate-income households.”
A decision in the case argued today is expected by the end of the year. Whatever the outcome, it appears that the EHO case will not be resolved in the courts for years.
To review court filings, legal briefs, and timelines, visit:
https://www.neighborsforneighborhoods.org/courtcase

